Werewolf: HNZ Birthday edition 🐺

[Saira Lykims]

At this point i'll just explain why i've been bandwagon-ing. (Like Amy/Clara said) I was confused and unsure of who to vote for and since there seemed to be a person who people were voting for, I trusted the crowd's judgement. (And also because there was an explanation which i understood and thought was sensible) I don't really understand (I think this is Luxen/Brian) people's reasoning for voting for Jace Blade, and I don't really understand why people are accusing Stanislaw either. Your replies are incredibly long, and it's getting a bit overwhelming for me. On another note, I understand Donna's vote for Brian, since he's also confusing me, and I also understand the vote for danny because he's been silent.

Thus, coming to my conclusion. I won't vote for Brian because he seems to be useful, though he is confusing. And since the other person with a vote is danny, I decided that his silence is somewhat suspicious. So, I will vote for Kard Thomas/Danny because he's not really contributing to the discussion (sorry danny, love you! uwuw). And that may be because he may be a wolf and is playing on that new card. And I suspect him, because most of the new players have still contributed in terms of voting. (and danny hasn't voted ) (again sorry!!!)

Also I don't really have any (edit: other) suspicions, most ppl here are just as equally suspicious for one reason or another.
(Wow this is my longest post yet) I should get to classes so byeeeeee. ill check on this later

 

[Willow Cullen]

so i just woke up (or rather just booted up my laptop after lying in bed reading my phone for a while, but that is surplus information)
I have skimmed four pages of conversation, I say skimmed as there is far too much information there to read in depth and keep looking back on. and you guys were so busy last night. goodness.

first f all thank you @Amy Rosemary for updating my table from yesterday. and thank you @Amber Chou Wilson for your table. both are very useful. and I good way to keep track of people bandwagoning (which I am surprised is actually a proper word).

my thoughts.
Brian. you talk so much. I can't keep up with you. this back and forward accusations does sound confusing and susspicious but at the moment to me it sounds like someone who is highly invested in the game and wants to win. which should be read as I think he is probably a villager but I am not sure.
I dont think Clara is that suspicious for outing the person who i suspected as being the drunk. I know it was decided on day one this was not a smart plan but there was a lot of discussion and it is quite easy for some things to be overlooked.

I will follow through with my promise from yesterday and vote for EMZIES/STEFAN ARCHER i am sticking with my gut on this one even if my head is reading though your posts and thinking of other suspects.

edit. Sorry I keep forgetting I signed up as @Selene Le Fey and my phone is logged in as willow. I am in fact Selene in disguise.

 

[Luxen Silverback II]

I had an idea, rather than just look for guilty by accusations what if we agreed for the doctor whomever they are to heal one person we all know (if the doctor heals a wolf they get killed along with whomever the wolf targets) we know that essentially the person picked for us to protect will then likely not be picked by the wolves for execution but at the same time we would know if that person is not a wolf or is a wolf based off the doctor being able to heal them.

For example I would say for whomever the doctor is, to heal Daphne since she is our best strategist so far and we would want to keep her another day and this would gurantee it. We don't want the doctor to reveal themselves so we would all essentially have to agree by post that the doctor should heal her and assume once night passed that they did but it would narrow the search since we have to assume the seer is dead or not able to give us real leads right now.

This might also be a better plan when the amount of people gets lower. We risk losing the doctor but we should assume they are healing and in hiding, so can't really reveal who isn't a wolf right now. Just a thought before I go to bed.

Edit: the doctor would have to likely keep protecting her to keep from her getting eaten the next night though...so probably not that good of a strategy

 

[Daisy Parker-Taylor]

I don't know if it'll help telling the doctor who to heal because then the wolves just won't vote to eat that person, right?

 

[Jace Blade]

Twice he has suggested RNG when it benefited the wolves more than the village.

I've literally only suggested RNG once, though? You're really stretching for reasons other than that honestly.

Yeah, I voted Teigan, I provided my reasoning why. Day 2 I had no leads so I wasn't going to vote for no reason - I suggested an RNG kill happen so that we'd have a chance at getting a wolf that wasn't just randomly ganging up on someone when we don't have adequate leads. Which, we can see where that took us.. another villager dead over a joke she made.

Your case on me in this case (ha ) is very flimsy, and it feels a bit like you're trying to push a mislynch.

 

[Kard Thomas]

wait ok so obviously i am active almost all the time and i do look at this a lot but the reason why im not talking is because i legit dont have anything to contribute in the first two days. theres so many people talking and voting that im just sitting here in front of my computer confused. i didnt vote because i really wasnt sure WHO to vote, even though i did suspect luxen/brian (i still do HAASBjh) i dont wanna vote without a solid reason, not just to bandwagon on the most voted one. since yall are suspecting me for not being active in the conversation and in voting, then ok sure ill talk more.

im still suspecting luxen/brian but im thinking hes more of a good guy than a wolf
im definitely suspecting saira/soho (sorry bebs) just because she was the only one who asked me (in messages) why i wasnt talking that much in the thread

thats all i gotta say for now, peace out u_u
(also my pronouns are they/them but its ok)

 

[Saira Lykims]

(Sorry Danny about the pronouns!!)

And also are we not allowed to ask in dms?? I probably shouldve asked before asking Danny. We were roleplaying the day before, so i asked them while dm-ing. Sorry if this is against the rules. (edit: luv u too <3)

 

[Jace Blade]

(Sorry Danny about the pronouns!!)

And also are we not allowed to ask in dms?? I probably shouldve asked before asking Danny. We were roleplaying the day before, so i asked them while dm-ing. Sorry if this is against the rules. (edit: luv u too <3)

all game chatter should be done in game thread or pms provided by the host

 

[Saira Lykims]

Won't make that mistake again, sorry!

 

[Monty Pendleton]

@Luxen Silverback II the doctor thing isn't a bad idea but we'd have no way of confirming they were actually healing said person, or even active, since they cant out themselves

Daph is right, Kard was a completely random pick for me to see what would happen i dont suspect him more than anyone else. However nobody has really come to his defence or piled on him and I reckon our chatter has put the wolves off voting at all

Has Kadi posted at all yet? I see her lurking all the time (but I know this game has been has been cray and there's a lot to catch up on)

 

[Luxen Silverback II]

I don't know if it'll help telling the doctor who to heal because then the wolves just won't vote to eat that person, right?

I'm also going to respond to @Monty Pendleton
Likely the wolves would essentially stay away from that person, so we would want to pick someone we believe is important, unfortunately I believe it might be a strategy for later due to the amount of people still in the game since it would require enough people to agree vocally and we would have to take a leap of faith and trust the doctor did it. It would just be nice to know someone beside the drunk is not a wolf lol at least it would kinda gurantee someone's survival.

 

[Amber Chou Wilson]

So the idea is that we decide who the doctor should heal and assume they do it and if they die we assume the person we picked is a wolf? Is that the idea?

 

[Luxen Silverback II]

So the idea is that we decide who the doctor should heal and assume they do it and if they die we assume the person we picked is a wolf? Is that the idea?

Essentially yes, but I would honestly hope they were innocent so we didn't lose the doctor. The doctor would likely have to keep healing the same person to keep them from being wolf chow but it would keep both the doctor safe (from accidentally picking a wolf if they are healing at random) and that person safe. We would have the added benefit of knowing that person is not a wolf. Unless the wolves decide to test if the doctor is working, I don't believe they would chose to target whoever we decide to protect.

Edit: it would be hard but we likely would want to try to protect the apprentice if possible, I know I'm not important so it would be wasteful for the doctor to heal me in this regard.

 

[Amber Chou Wilson]

There feels something off about us as a whole deciding what the doctor should do. I also want to ask Pheeb if the doctor can heal the same person the entire time?

I was hoping to have a clearer person to vote for today. But so far I don't really know what to do.

 

[Jace Blade]

I know I'm not important so it would be wasteful for the doctor to heal me in this regard.

Are you not important or is there no point since you're a wolf?

 

[Willow Cullen]

healing the apprentice may not necesserily be a good idea. depending on who they are apprenticing under there is a chance that we would be protecting a wolf pup (if you get my drift). plus it would leave them vulnerable if the doctor decides that someone else is at risk of being eaten. and protects them.
edit: and that is assuming we still have an apprentice and that they haven't already taken over someone's role.


edit. Sorry I keep forgetting I signed up as @Selene Le Fey and my phone is logged in as willow. I am in fact Selene in disguise.

 

[Amy Jewel]

Are you not important or is there no point since you're a wolf?

After reading everything today, I thought the same.

it would be hard but we likely would want to try to protect the apprentice if possible

If the doctor can't heal the same person again, wouldn't that put the apprentice in the firing line? (Mia posted while I was typing, and I agree, protecting a future wolf wouldn't be the best).

I was hoping to have a clearer person to vote for today. But so far I don't really know what to do.

I honestly spent all day thinking about who to vote for while skimming the conversation and I feel this too.

 

[Sara Moon]

I think we will learn most from lynching Steven or Zach. I’m not sure which I want to vote for. There’s a lot of theories bouncing around so that may sway My vote but I’ll check back later again

 

[Luxen Silverback II]

the apprentice allowed to apprentice a wolf? or they don't know who they are apprenticing, sorry I don't really know all the little rules when it comes to the special characters. It says the doctor can only heal themselves once per game so I was kinda assuming they could heal someone else as many times as they want...

I'm not saying it has to be the apprentice btw I just figured if they could chose which role they were apprenticing then maybe they had chosen to apprentice the doctor or seer but that was before I knew they could apprentice a wolf.

I have said multiple times I'm not important because it's the truth so I'm good with being lynched or eaten by a wolf. I don't expect to survive till the end so when I go is when I go.

Edit: the big goal with the doctor suggestion is to give everyone someone that is active and experienced and we know if not a wolf that would be protected long enough to hunt down the wolves and take a more leadership role rather than just rely on guessing who is trustworthy out of a crowd obviously if Jesse were alive he would have been the clear choice to pick.

Edit edit: I do talk alot, worse case was we lose a doctor but we also find a wolf

Edit edit edit: sorry I think alot so I talk alot, if it will put the matter to rest as far as whether I'm being honest about my role than I will volunteer to be the person the doctor heals first and then we can pick someone else tomorrow. I don't care if the wolves kill me the next day and everyone would know before my death if I was really telling the truth or not. I know we would still have to assume the doctor healed me but it's something.

 

[Harper Alston]

The rules say the apprentice chooses a person at the beginning of the game, so I'm assuming they don't know which role they'll get until that person dies. I could be wrong though.

I'm currently suspicious of Brian and Clara, for many of the same reasons as Daphne. Though I can't tell if Brian is just playing the game very aggressively.

I'm also really suspicious of Verity and Soho. Both voted for Zennon and Cyndi late in the game. It strikes me that a smart strategy for a new player would be to bandwagon late and play it off as inexperience for the first few rounds. It was also safer for a new person (as opposed to an experienced player) to bandwagon since most of the scrutiny in the first two rounds has been on the experienced players.

 

[Amber Chou Wilson]

I don't believe the apprentice knows what the role of the person they picked is until that person dies. I also don't see why it can't be a wolf.

 

[Luxen Silverback II]

I don't believe the apprentice knows what the role of the person they picked is until that person dies. I also don't see why it can't be a wolf.

I was assuming they were apprenticing based off roles rather than people dang that really stacks the deck against the villagers lol

 

[Amber Chou Wilson]

Apprentice - At the beginning of the game, you will choose one person to be your role model. If this person dies, you will take on their role. It will not be announced that the Apprentice has picked up their new job.

Person, not role. You can't be the apprentice and say 'I want to apprentice the doctor' but instead you go 'I want to apprentice [name]' at least from my understanding.

That does mean statistically it is most likely the apprentice is just a villager with extra steps.

 

[Luxen Silverback II]

Person, not role. You can't be the apprentice and say 'I want to apprentice the doctor' but instead you go 'I want to apprentice [name]' at least from my understanding.

That does mean statistically it is most likely the apprentice is just a villager with extra steps.

Yeah I saw that after the apprenticing wolf thing was brought up so pretty much the only special character we can really assume the villagers get is the doctor since the seer/fool doesn't know they are and therefore are unrealiable and with so many villagers it's unlikely the apprentice got a good role to apprentice.

 

[Amber Chou Wilson]

Yeah I saw that after the apprenticing wolf thing was brought up so pretty much the only special character we can really assume the villagers get is the doctor since the seer/fool doesn't know they are and therefore are unrealiable and with so many villagers it's unlikely the apprentice got a good role to apprentice.

The seer/fool can check fairly easily if they are the seer or the fool if they have been paying attention.