Valentine Werewolf

[Charlotte Owens]

I find it weird that Sally wants to be voted out. Why sign up if you just want to get out? However, somehow I don't think it's her but I do see people's reasons why she could be. At this point I'm a bit confused so I will save my vote for later.

 

[Stefan Archer]

Well there is a great feeling about saying you are something, folk not really believing you and then proving them wrong
​

 

[Evelyn Manning]

I didn't played the last game but I seriously have no clue who to vote for. Perhaps saying things like Sally does is a technique or something, it sure is but I'm still voting for her. I guess she is more than a normal villiager.

 

[Chyou Jin Howard]

Dear Merlin I srsly have nothing to lose .
im xtremely suspicious of Dan, why follow the crowds just to kill another villager?
Jamie Smells a bit fishy to me too.

When I turn out to die as an innocent villager, u guys know who to lynch next

 

[Amy Rosemary]

Guys. What if all the wolves are plotting with each other (is that even allowed?)

I don't know, I just have a feeling that whoever killed Marisol had something to do with jealousy, either that or that they saw her as a threat or traitor because she's muggle born? Who could possibly want her eliminated? -_-

Edit: Excuse me if I'm completely off, but what if one of the wolves is targeting characters that are not as active as others in the game? Maybe it's all connected

 

[Katherine Alicastell]

???
In previous games the Wolves could talk amongst themselves during the Night Phase so the same rules probably apply to this game.

On the topic of Sally, I don't wholly suspect her of being a wolf as she's playing the same way she did last game, but I can see it as also being a strategy if she were a wolf.

I feel like Dan was eager to jump onto the Sally bandwagon. I don't like mob trains unless there's a strong enough argument, but all Dan offered was "I agree let's kill someone."

 

[Teagan Riley]

I don't think it's Sally either but I'm beginning to suspect Jamie and Dan. I didn't vote the first night and 2 villagers gone already. I vote to lynch Evelyn Manning. Sorry, Jamie. You seems playing safe
​

 

[Aurora Night]

Hmm, I don't really have a strategy for finding wolves this game... Sally I think is most likely not a wolf, and I get why Dan seems suspicious, but other than that I'm kind of looking at Pat and Cyndi since they were the first ones to start voting yesterday. I don't like the idea of voting on the first day without any clear evidence, because, as happened again, we didn't get a wolf... so they were keen to vote and relatively quiet afterwards, particularly Pat.

I won't make a vote yet today though, I'll wait to see what else comes up.

 

[Cyndi Kingsley]

I feel like Dan was eager to jump onto the Sally bandwagon. I don't like mob trains unless there's a strong enough argument, but all Dan offered was "I agree let's kill someone."

He jumped on the Silus one as well. For now, I'll vote to lynch James Cade.

 

[Chyou Jin Howard]

I feel like Dan was eager to jump onto the Sally bandwagon. I don't like mob trains unless there's a strong enough argument, but all Dan offered was "I agree let's kill someone."

He jumped on the Silus one as well. For now, I'll vote to lynch James Cade.

I second that, I vote to lynch James Cade

 

[Professor Lyra Potter]

I'm with Cyndi and Sally. I'm suspicious of anyone that voted for Silus because Carrie clearly wasn't a threat. She hadn't even been online since the game started. It seemed like a really bad move. I'm voting to lynch James Cade.

 

[Katherine Alicastell]

I dislike that everyone is calling it a bad move. Lynching a wolf on the first day was an extremely slim chance. I think that if we hadn't voted for Carrie, it was likely that we still might have killed a villager.
Her not being online since the game started didn't rule out her being a wolf, since there were still four wolves, and only one of those wolves would need to be active to make a kill.

---

Of course Carrie comes online today.

Also here are the current votes

Evelynn Manning - 1
Chyou Jin Howard - 3
James Cade - 3

Because as Cyndi has mentioned Dan boarding both the Carrie and Sally bandwagons, I'll opt to vote for James Cade to bring Sally out of the danger, since she seems to be less suspicious than Dan.

Bringing it to
Evelynn Manning - 1
Chyou Jin Howard - 3
James Cade - 4

 

[Sarah Keith]

I agree that Dan is more suspicious than Sally, because of the reason stated by Cyndi. Therefore, I vote to lynch James Cade.

 

[Ai Nightray]

I don't see how voting for Silus could be seen as threatening or suspicious at all seeing as how none of us really had anything to go by in lynching. Besides, seeing as there's a whole bunch of wolves, a kill could still be made even if one of them hadn't been online throughout the game. I'm more suspicious of Sally than Dan to be honest seeing as how she's quite eager to throw herself out there and while Dan is just jumping on the bandwagon I don't see how jumping on Carrie and Sally is suspicious at the moment as we were nearly going on random voting in the first day and Sally is volunteering. For now, I vote to lynch Chyou Howard.
​

 

[Chyou Jin Howard]

I don't see how voting for Silus could be seen as threatening or suspicious at all seeing as how none of us really had anything to go by in lynching. Besides, seeing as there's a whole bunch of wolves, a kill could still be made even if one of them hadn't been online throughout the game. I'm more suspicious of Sally than Dan to be honest seeing as how she's quite eager to throw herself out there and while Dan is just jumping on the bandwagon I don't see how jumping on Carrie and Sally is suspicious at the moment as we were nearly going on random voting in the first day and Sally is volunteering. For now, I vote to lynch Chyou Howard.
​

I don't think I'd want to lynch myself if I were to be a wolf... Cz that's an interesting and rare role ... Just saying..
Again, I have no flock to lose. I really have nothing to lose when I die as a villager.
How am I fishy just because I voted for myself? XD I'd like to start every game with lynching myself just to get Katniss' spirit out here

 

[Ai Nightray]

I don't see how voting for Silus could be seen as threatening or suspicious at all seeing as how none of us really had anything to go by in lynching. Besides, seeing as there's a whole bunch of wolves, a kill could still be made even if one of them hadn't been online throughout the game. I'm more suspicious of Sally than Dan to be honest seeing as how she's quite eager to throw herself out there and while Dan is just jumping on the bandwagon I don't see how jumping on Carrie and Sally is suspicious at the moment as we were nearly going on random voting in the first day and Sally is volunteering. For now, I vote to lynch Chyou Howard.
​

I don't think I'd want to lynch myself if I were to be a wolf... Cz that's an interesting and rare role ... Just saying..
Again, I have no flock to lose. I really have nothing to lose when I die as a villager.
How am I fishy just because I voted for myself? XD I'd like to start every game with lynching myself just to get Katniss' spirit out here

This is the first time I played with you though! So how would I know you ain't calling a bluff on me?
​

 

[Chyou Jin Howard]

I don't see how voting for Silus could be seen as threatening or suspicious at all seeing as how none of us really had anything to go by in lynching. Besides, seeing as there's a whole bunch of wolves, a kill could still be made even if one of them hadn't been online throughout the game. I'm more suspicious of Sally than Dan to be honest seeing as how she's quite eager to throw herself out there and while Dan is just jumping on the bandwagon I don't see how jumping on Carrie and Sally is suspicious at the moment as we were nearly going on random voting in the first day and Sally is volunteering. For now, I vote to lynch Chyou Howard.
​

I don't think I'd want to lynch myself if I were to be a wolf... Cz that's an interesting and rare role ... Just saying..
Again, I have no flock to lose. I really have nothing to lose when I die as a villager.
How am I fishy just because I voted for myself? XD I'd like to start every game with lynching myself just to get Katniss' spirit out here

This is the first time I played with you though! So how would I know you ain't calling a bluff on me?
​

I might be a bored villager

 

[Teagan Riley]

I'm revoking my first vote and change it to James Cade. I have a list of suspects but for now I'll stick to Dan.

I vote to lynch James Cade
​

 

[Chyou Jin Howard]

If I turn out to be dead tonight, then please know that my suspicion falls on Dan and Marga *sorry guys *

 

[Professor James Cade]

By all means kill another villager. Even though I've done nothing but agree with previous stated suspicions.

Its also interesting that people are happy to jump on the bandwagon and vote for me because I jumped on the bandwagon. Of course now Sally is playing innocent after volunteering for the first day.

 

[Chyou Jin Howard]

I am ready to die off with her head!!

 

[Professor James Cade]

I am ready to die off with her head!!

I'm trying to have you killed but that's just getting me killed.

 

[Daisy Parker-Taylor]

I'm still withholding my vote I think, but Sally is giving me whiplash! She claims innocence but then also volunteers and I just don't know. It's suspicious to me but I don't want to lynch just for the sake of lynching.

 

[Sara Moon]

I feel Sally suggesting she wants to die, could possibly be indicative of her being the white wolf? Since being lynched is how they win the game, if I understand correctly. As such, I vote to lynch James Cade, because I don't want the white wolf to win, and because I do find it suspicious that he jumped on the bandwagon, and then only joined the conversation about voting when he had been suggested as a person to be lynched. Sorry Dan

 

[Amy Rosemary]

I vote to lynch James Cade as well, sorry Dan Currently I don't have enough time to explain, but most of my suspicions have been mentioned by everyone, so although Sally and Marga both seem suspicious to me, I'm more skeptic of Dan (is that the right word?).

Claire has a good point, so I'll keep my suspicions for the next round.
I'm still having doubts about Dan not being the wolf, so please forgive me if I am wrong