Werewolf: HNZ Birthday edition 🐺

[Luxen Silverback II]

I delete before I post, it's really something I write down to get it out of my head even if I don't intend to post it. I might edit misspelled words or add to something I think is incomplete, but rarely do I feel the need to delete something once it's out. Hope that makes it a bit clearer.

 

[Monty Pendleton]

Having read everything over I'm changing my vote to Luxen Silverback but i will check in again later too

I keep feeling like he could be a wolf trying to figure out who has an inconsequential role so that he knows who not to bother targeting

Edit: The 'don't heal me' thing was pretty sus too though

 

[Amber Chou Wilson]

I'm not entirely on the 'Brian is a wolf' train because I definitely get enthusiastic player vibes, but as I mentioned before him saying the doctor should heal one person could be suspicious too as wolves then know all other people aren't safe and can pick them off? But I can also see it as a genuine strategy.

 

[Stan Beckett]

Having read everything over I'm changing my vote to Luxen Silverback but i will check in again later too

I keep feeling like he could be a wolf trying to figure out who has an inconsequential role so that he knows who not to bother targeting

Edit: The 'don't heal me' thing was pretty sus too though

 

[Monty Pendleton]

Your response makes me think I misread something again but I'm on my phone and will have to check later

I thought Brian had said not to bother healing him but maybe he did not

 

[Luxen Silverback II]

I didn't want to say it till tomorrow but since I'm likely out anyways and it may be some use for tomorrow, I would like to point out that Harper Alston/Ana used RNG both days to get her votes could be innocent but it could also be used as a method of looking like voting, while not accusing anyone, and not jumping on any bandwagons which would be a good method for a wolf to employ.

 

[Luxen Silverback II]

Your response makes me think I misread something again but I'm on my phone and will have to check later

I thought Brian had said not to bother healing him but maybe he did not

I did but I edited twice later before anyone responded suggesting that it could be used to prove my innocence so that I would volunteer to be the first person and then the doctor could heal someone else afterwards again like Mia said and I don't deny, I talk alot lol

 

[Amber Chou Wilson]

Maybe clarify what this means Steven?

 

[Sara Moon]

Okay, won't lie, feeling a bit unwell (no panic, just sore stomach) so the lying in bed is giving me time to think at least. I'm taking a different route with the Brian asking to be healed, because if he were a wolf, and the doctor listened to him, he'd be immediately outed. It's too early in the game for a wolf to risk outing themselves. It's making me less suspicious of him. That said, the only theory that still feels like it has some weight to me, is the experienced player theory. Now, out of the people I find suspicious, I think one team is emerging a bit; Zach and Dan seem to be on the same vibe. Dan hasn't voted at all on the first two days, and has jumped in today to defend Zach. He spoke on other days, suggesting that we shouldn't lynch for inactivity on day one. Dan is experienced, he knows that the wolves often lie low to begin, and begin to intervene when people are on the right track quite often. I'm not sure yet, but I'm interested to see if anyone else finds this suspect?

Edit: Dan also jumped in to say Clara didn't need a reason to not think Zach was a wolf. Less damning, but interesting.

 

[Stan Beckett]

Maybe clarify what this means Steven?

It means that I am suspicious of Claire. She's been on me since Cyndi died but now she's switching over to vote for Brian instead because he may have said something which could make him suspicious.

EDIT: I also don't believe that she missed the fact that Mia and Verity also jumped in on voting for Cyndi once that started happening, but she did exclude them from her supposed 'alliance'

 

[Monty Pendleton]

I'm gonna go ahead and say it just cus he's as good as outed already - Dan is more than likely the drunk, so I'm not suspicious of him defending anyone

@Stanislaw Kurek I said I was going to start ruffling a few feathers in the hopes of learning from people's reactions I had no suspicion on me when the day began so I knew I was taking a risk, but I'm curious how it'll pan out

I may change my vote again yet

 

[Luxen Silverback II]

I'm gonna go ahead and say it just cus he's as good as outed already - Dan is more than likely the drunk, so I'm not suspicious of him defending anyone

@Stanislaw Kurek I said I was going to start ruffling a few feathers in the hopes of learning from people's reactions I had no suspicion on me when the day began so I knew I was taking a risk, but I'm curious how it'll pan out

I may change my vote again yet

Careful with that because it could get you killed lol

Edit: honestly I think the whole defend everyone approach is counter productive and just gives the wolves a chance to hide more. My biggest issue that I have seen is over analyzing especially those that are active and participating which in turn gives the wolves more incentive to just keep quiet and let the villagers kill themselves. We go round and round rather than forcing wolves to actually act suspiciously because all they have to do is pipe up say sorry I was busy or sorry I am new and the inactivity is then basically excused and then they can continue hiding and killing off villagers. Just some thoughts since I'm going to die and you will get to see I was just a lowly villager after all lol

 

[Sara Moon]

See I don't know if he is though, because while his posts are short, lots of people aren't very active and it'd be a very clever move to pose as the drunk, because the only proof of not being would be posting over 20, so you could self-impose that restriction to pretend to be the drunk, yknow?

 

[Monty Pendleton]

I just didn't look super hard Steven - but I feel like drawing attention to the people who voted for Cyndi would be a silly move if someone I wanted to protect had also voted for her

I would have just ignored it conpletely

 

[Monty Pendleton]

See I don't know if he is though, because while his posts are short, lots of people aren't very active and it'd be a very clever move to pose as the drunk, because the only proof of not being would be posting over 20, so you could self-impose that restriction to pretend to be the drunk, yknow?

It's too risky, the real drunk could show up at any second and Dan would be insta-outed as a wolf for trying to pretend to be it

 

[Selene Le Fey]

I am lost. like 100% lost.
can the wolves please eat me tonight so I have my brain processing power back to put on important things.
Thank you.

See I don't know if he is though, because while his posts are short, lots of people aren't very active and it'd be a very clever move to pose as the drunk, because the only proof of not being would be posting over 20, so you could self-impose that restriction to pretend to be the drunk, yknow?

That is true. however can you find one other person who has either consistently posted below 20 words or not posted at all?
i mean most of the short posts I have seen are still over 20 words. or the same person has just posted big before and just had one more thing to add.

 

[Amy Rosemary]

I simply withheld my vote because I’m constantly confused now with the game, and then I had lunch and now I’m back on but I still have to get stuff done offline. Also so much has happened that I completely forgot about the whole ‘not mentioning who a specific role is because it’s unsafe’ decision.

Anyways, right now my suspicions are on Clara and Emzies. I am naturally wary of Emzies because she hasn't managed to vote (although the same goes with Kadi). Though she claims to be forgetful, I wonder if that's true in this case or is she just using it as an excuse this time? Clara because of the comment regarding a role that really should have been left alone and aside from that not wanting to vote because it would be considered jumping on the bandwagon. I wouldn't have found you that suspicious with the Cyndi bandwagon considering that few people voted yesterday, however saying that you'll be withholding your vote so that you won't be considered jumping on bandwagons - now that I found suspicious. It's like you're trying so hard to not be looked at too closely.

I did think I could look suspicious by saying that but honestly in my opinion i think most people are at some point whether they jump on a bandwagon or not. I admit it would be a smart tactic but I’m not very good at this game anyway.

So I’m just going to go for it, I highly doubt my death would help the village much, given that I’m probably not contributing things that are useful as much as other people in the discussion, but I have my suspicions (as everyone else does).

Brian is definitely suspicious to me because of how active he is, and how extremely confusing this game got for me (still is pretty confusing). At first I did suspect him as a wolf, but now I’m leaning towards more that he isn’t, and is just eager to get a wolf. If I overthink things too much that’s what gets me confused in the first place, so I’m not going to vote for him based on whether his death is or isn’t very useful to the village. I might start to second guess and doubt myself so I’m just not going to vote for him now.

I also find someone else suspicious but I don’t want to say who yet because I don’t have a proper explanation for It yet

See I don't know if he is though, because while his posts are short, lots of people aren't very active and it'd be a very clever move to pose as the drunk, because the only proof of not being would be posting over 20, so you could self-impose that restriction to pretend to be the drunk, yknow?

Wow I was about to say this too before I read your post surely a wolf can pretend to be a role even if it’s not a villager because if I were a wolf I’d definitely try to hide my identity in some way. And seeing as he is experienced, I’m fairly convinced Dan is either one of the two.

 

[Amy Rosemary]

It's too risky, the real drunk could show up at any second and Dan would be insta-outed as a wolf for trying to pretend to be it

Yeah but again you couldn’t be too sure if the second person or the original drunk is actually the drunk or a wolf.

 

[Sara Moon]

I genuinely don't know who to vote for, if I vote for Zach and he's innocent, then it's likely Dan is just the drunk, and will give some insight on where Brian's allegiance lies. If I vote for Zach and he's a wolf, then Dan is a super crafty wolf. So, I think Zach's death would teach us the most. ~But then lynching Brian would lead us to Zach. The voting pattern for Brian so far doesn't give much insight, but if he's innocent makes Steven, Zach and Dan look guilty because they're all gunning for him fairly hard. It's a quagmire.

 

[Luxen Silverback II]

See I don't know if he is though, because while his posts are short, lots of people aren't very active and it'd be a very clever move to pose as the drunk, because the only proof of not being would be posting over 20, so you could self-impose that restriction to pretend to be the drunk, yknow?

I actually checked before the end of the second day either Dan is the drunk or the drunk broke the rules. I called him out day 2 to avoid having to check all the posts but he was silent so I ended up having to do that.

Edit: I don't mind saying that because it's literally already pointed at him and the wolves could easily have done or do what I did so not trying to be malicious or anything

 

[Sara Moon]

Okay, that's useful. Then I don't suspect Dan, thanks for checking because I don;t think my brain could take that right now.

 

[Amy Rosemary]

I actually checked before the end of the second day either Dan is the drunk or the drunk broke the rules. I called him out day 2 to avoid having to check all the posts but he was silent so I ended up having to do that.

I literally read the roles just yesterday but I forgot already Doesn’t the drunk die if they post more than 20 words anyway? So I highly doubt they broke the rules.

Edit: the wolves are really getting to us

 

[Stan Beckett]

I genuinely don't know who to vote for, if I vote for Zach and he's innocent, then it's likely Dan is just the drunk, and will give some insight on where Brian's allegiance lies. If I vote for Zach and he's a wolf, then Dan is a super crafty wolf. So, I think Zach's death would teach us the most. ~But then lynching Brian would lead us to Zach. The voting pattern for Brian so far doesn't give much insight, but if he's innocent makes Steven, Zach and Dan look guilty because they're all gunning for him fairly hard. It's a quagmire.

Tbf I did also vote for Brian on the first day, not sure if that would make a difference. It just really doesn't matter who we're voting for at this point because we don't know anything. My reasoning for going for Brian again today is so that we may get at least a little bit of clarity back since he has been the one causing confusion all around.

 

[Amber Chou Wilson]

I don't get why the drunk had to be outed like this. It's not that difficult to go back and check who has posted with less than 20 words and figure out there is no other option. So all this talk about it makes me suspicious of those drawing attention to it on purpose, which here have been Claire, Maia and Clara.

I also don't get this:

I also find someone else suspicious but I don’t want to say who yet because I don’t have a proper explanation for It yet

Plenty of people including myself have called people suspicious based on a hunch or a feeling. Not naming someone but mentioning it anyway is just not helpful. If you die and you're a wolf you'll have mentioned someone's suspicious but not who, meaning we can't cross anyone off the wolf list.

 

[Monty Pendleton]

Ughh this is too hard

If Brian is a wolf I would suspect Maia and Clara for trying to take the vote off him. If he's not a wolf I would trust them a little more because they have no reason to keep Brian alive

Therefore killing Brian may help either way

I don't get why the drunk had to be outed like this. It's not that difficult to go back and check who has posted with less than 20 words and figure out there is no other option. So all this talk about it makes me suspicious of those drawing attention to it on purpose, which here have been Claire, Maia and Clara.

Maia suspected Dan and Zach of being a team. That seemed odd to me, since it's so obvious (as you say) that Dan is the drunk. Seemed like a diversion of some kind. I had no problem pointing this out because it's already super clear to everyone that Dan is the drunk and it's not putting him at risk for me to say that