Lyra Potter said:
Maybe you were trying to save Ash.
Yes, maybe I was trying to save Ash by bringing her
back into the random lynching once she tried to put Steph in the lead with three votes. I thought Ash was the villager, but once she voted I couldn't trust that she was - and I'm glad I didn't.
As to where you've quoted me, the key words are "wolf or villager" - saving yourself makes sense either way. I was drawing attention to the sudden thought that the reason Teigan might have died was because the wolves were trying to make me seem suspicious. Once you were safe you didn't need to switch your vote to Abby that day, particularly so late in the game when it was clear that votes for either of us weren't going to amount to anything - you were the seventh to vote for her, and by that stage every vote is pretty much a bandwagon one (Dan was sixth and Lovi was ninth by the way guys).
As for my use of the word "panic," it stems mostly from this:
What happens if there is a tie? Is everyone lynched? Or just a random person out of the three?
I feel like this is an important question I need answered before I place my vote.
Okay so I don't really want to leave this up to a random generator.
The breaks indicate that you posted all of those quite close together - perhaps because no one was answering your important question. It was important, I agree. But trusting me to be a villager like I say I am, with only one other villager in play, a three-way tie would have resulted in likely 2/3 odds of lynching a wolf
and 3/3 odds if you had been the other villager. Even if you didn't trust me to be who I said I was, why wouldn't you go for the 2/3 odds? It's not like we were making huge headway in leads otherwise that day (or that you were trying to find wolves, which, when
was the last time you actively decided to do that?
Expressed sympathy for Zach/Waiting to see who else is around
Says that the first day sucks and she's happy waiting
Says that she doesn't see how she's suspicious by doing what everyone else does/Voted for Kathy to save herself and that she might not be able to post because of work e.g. reason for not changing her vote later
Says that Kathy's argument is convincing, switched vote to Abby
Explained her inactivity, and that she'll try to vote before it closes (which she never ended up doing)
Posted a gif implying she's spell-casted
Had a waving gif - like she's still here
Defending herself in retrospect, as she was silenced yesterday/Doesn't really agree with all the people in the innocent category, but is voting for Lovi
Believes Claire is the seer/Is suspicious of Jesse and thinks he might be the sorceress/Thinks we're at three wolves, but likely missed the Cursed night
Says she's a villager, and that Jesse came after her with no real reasoning on Day 2 (which he did have reasoning), making her suspicious of him
Says she'll be busy, and that she's voting with Phoebe, a proven innocent
Panicked at the prospect of a random number generator decided vote (2/3 if not 3/3 odds of getting a wolf) and so voted for Ash as she seemed the most threatening and lynchable of those she was suspicious of (before the day phase usually closes, too)
Oh, it looks like it was never. What about your votes? We've already covered Day 2 - the next time you voted was for Lovi (who the Seer outed, so why not look innocent and vote for her). Then it was Maia, who was fairly safe to go with as Phoebe suggested her (Phoebe was innocent, Phoebe we could trust!) - yours was the third and final nail in Maia's coffin, and you knew she wasn't a wolf.
And then you voted for Ash. Who knows why you would do that, unless you were throwing her under the bus. She probably hasn't been very active even among you wolves, if that night no one died is anything to go by - wasn't that the night right after you'd been off on that big trip to Disneyland and you were running on no sleep? Jesse did seem very insistent that we consider the Cursed might not have been activated that night, after all. I'm considering it.
Regardless, I remain convinced Steph is not the wolf-wolf, convinced that Jesse is not an original wolf (and therefore his rivalry with you beginning in the early stages of the game does not make you a villager), and that the lack of Rowan's activity means he can only be a wolf if he's teamed with you as a wolf (because I believe Steph is not the wolf, and he and Jesse can't be a team).
It's all pointing back to you Kait.