Book Club: September/October

What book should we read for September/October?

  • The Haunting of Hill House

    Votes: 5 71.4%
  • How to Sell a Haunted House

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Our Wicked Histories

    Votes: 2 28.6%
  • The Devil in the White City

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    7

Poppy Perkins

chronically enthusiastic🌼 illustrator 🌼'56 grad
 
Messages
1,606
OOC First Name
Kadi
Blood Status
Muggleborn
Relationship Status
Interested in Somebody
Wand
Knotted 12 Inch Sturdy Vine Wand with Hippogriff Feather Core
Age
03/2038 (25)
Hello everyone!! It's somehow my turn to help pick the next book club book and this time I will actually finish it I promise!! But despite it being over 100F/37C the past week I am manifesting spooky season here and now, and I went with a bit of a haunted house theme. I tried to pick a decent variety within that theme with hopefully limited spooks with some of them. Below I have listed the title and summaries with links to their respective Goodreads pages.

For a "classic" I went with The Haunting of Hill House by Shirley Jackson
182 pages. I've read a little by Shirley Jackson and liked it all so far.
It is the story of four seekers who arrive at a notoriously unfriendly pile called Hill House: Dr. Montague, an occult scholar looking for solid evidence of a "haunting"; Theodora, the lighthearted assistant; Eleanor, a friendless, fragile young woman well acquainted with poltergeists; and Luke, the future heir of Hill House. At first, their stay seems destined to be merely a spooky encounter with inexplicable phenomena. But Hill House is gathering its powers—and soon it will choose one of them to make its own.

For a "modern" option I went with How to Sell a Haunted House by Grady Hendrix
419 pages. I've heard good things about this author but haven't read any yet, so why not start here.
Grady Hendrix takes on the haunted house in a thrilling new novel that explores the way your past—and your family—can haunt you like nothing else.

When Louise finds out her parents have died, she dreads going home. She doesn’t want to leave her daughter with her ex and fly to Charleston. She doesn’t want to deal with her family home, stuffed to the rafters with the remnants of her father’s academic career and her mother’s lifelong obsession with puppets and dolls. She doesn’t want to learn how to live without the two people who knew and loved her best in the world.

Most of all, she doesn’t want to deal with her brother, Mark, who never left their hometown, gets fired from one job after another, and resents her success. Unfortunately, she’ll need his help to get the house ready for sale because it’ll take more than some new paint on the walls and clearing out a lifetime of memories to get this place on the market.

But some houses don’t want to be sold, and their home has other plans for both of them…

For a YA option I went with Our Wicked Histories by Amy Goldsmith
384 pages. Don't know a lot about this one but picked it in the hopes it might be a less scary option, maybe?
A teen girl’s attempt to make amends with her former friend group takes a sinister turn during a weekend getaway at an ancestral Irish estate in this atmospheric, literary horror from the author of Those We Drown.

There’s something in the lake at Wren Hall.

At least, that’s what the locals say. Not that Meg cares much about the rumors. When she’s asked to spend Halloween weekend at the Ireland retreat of the wealthy Wren twins, she recognizes the invitation for exactly what it her last, and only, chance to save her spot at Greyscott’s, the exclusive British art school she attended on scholarship until last summer. Clever, beautiful, and talented, the twins are the pride of Greyscott’s, and kindhearted Lottie Wren was once Meg’s closest friends. But not anymore.

None of Meg’s old friend group have talked to her since she left school—and they especially don’t talk about the incident that resulted in her suspension. Now, Meg is willing to do whatever it takes to earn their forgiveness.

But Wren Hall turns out to be far from the idyllic country manor Meg was expecting. The house is damp and drafty, the mirrors are all covered, and the weed-choked lake is at the center of legends that haunt the property to this day—a tainted legacy the estate seems unable to shake.

The truth is, people aren’t the only ones who keep secrets. Places can keep them too—and Wren Hall is drowning in them. When the past bleeds into the present and ancient sins rise to the surface, Meg must ask herself how well she really knows her one-time best friends...or whether any of them will survive the weekend.

And for a nonfiction wild card I picked, The Devil in the White City: Murder, Magic, and Madness at the Fair That Changed America by Erik Larson
464 pages. Honestly this is just a book I've wanted to read for a while and I've heard it's really good. Might just be the architecture nerd in me speaking lol
Author Erik Larson imbues the incredible events surrounding the 1893 Chicago World's Fair with such drama that readers may find themselves checking the book's categorization to be sure that 'The Devil in the White City' is not, in fact, a highly imaginative novel. Larson tells the stories of two men: Daniel H. Burnham, the architect responsible for the fair's construction, and H.H. Holmes, a serial killer masquerading as a charming doctor.

Burnham's challenge was immense. In a short period of time, he was forced to overcome the death of his partner and numerous other obstacles to construct the famous "White City" around which the fair was built. His efforts to complete the project, and the fair's incredible success, are skillfully related along with entertaining appearances by such notables as Buffalo Bill Cody, Susan B. Anthony, and Thomas Edison.

The activities of the sinister Dr. Holmes, who is believed to be responsible for scores of murders around the time of the fair, are equally remarkable. He devised and erected the World's Fair Hotel, complete with crematorium and gas chamber, near the fairgrounds and used the event as well as his own charismatic personality to lure victims.

Combining the stories of an architect and a killer in one book, mostly in alternating chapters, seems like an odd choice but it works. The magical appeal and horrifying dark side of 19th-century Chicago are both revealed through Larson's skillful writing. - John Moe

This poll will be open for 7 days, so get your votes in quick! Once the lucky winner emerges, we'll have two months to discuss and enjoy in this thread, before the next poll begins. I hope there's something here people are interested in!

React/discuss at your own pace. All of us are differing levels of busy and differing levels of how much we can read at once, so remember to use spoilers for spoiler-related content so you don't spoil for others! Please be respectful in this regard.

Site rules apply to all discussions. Be aware that books may contain mature themes or language.

The current book club leader schedule is as follows;
Jan/Feb - Cyndi
Mar/Apr- Rowan
May/Jun- Mia
Jul/Aug- Sarah
Sep/Oct- Kadi

Nov/Dec- Daphne
Anyone keen to take the lead in future should let Cyndi know!
 
Oooooooooooooh I love a theme!!!

I'm not necessarily great with horror, so this'll be an interesting one for me lol. I'm pretty torn between the last two options - the YA one sounds really interesting, but I'm a sucker for true crime stuff & I find Dr. Holmes' whole story fascinating - it sounds fantastical that he was able to get away with so much. Gonna have to have a think on this one, but I'm very keen for either of those two!
 
I went a different direction and picked the first one cuz I’ve seen the show :lol: very interested in these though
 
Went with the Shirley Jackson book because it's the shortest :p and because I've liked all of the other Jackson stories I've read! I also have the Grady Hendrix book on my list so hoping that one wins if Jackson doesn't. :lol:
 
Last edited:
I'm voting Our Wicked Histories because that was the only one already on my TBR :r

Now I'm wondering if I should do a theme..
 
Went with Haunting of Hill House because I already own that book and I just haven't gotten around to reading it (and as said before, it is short lol). I would've maybe gone for the true crime option but I've read that one. It's a good read but it does go into the Chicago World Fair a lot so fair warning if you're expecting something that's more 'pure' true crime.
 
Changed my mind after all and went for Haunting of Hill House. I think if we're gonna do horror my chicken ass needs it to be short, and it'd be nice to read one that's become such a staple of the genre.

Also, @Cyndi Kingsley since we're getting close to the end of the list could I go back on to lead one again soon? :wub:
 
Also, @Cyndi Kingsley since we're getting close to the end of the list could I go back on to lead one again soon? :wub:
Yep, Mar/Apr, May/June, and Nov/Dec are still available. Let me know which block you're interested in.
 
Yep, Mar/Apr, May/June, and Nov/Dec are still available. Let me know which block you're interested in.
Yay!! I'll go for Mar/Apr again in that case :party:
 
I think there's still technically a day or so left to vote but it looks like a pretty decisive The Haunting of Hill House sweep!

I have read her book, We Have Always Lived in the Castle, which wasn't that scary and leaned more in a surreal/unsettling direction. So hopefully it'll fall in that direction too, although I think the reviews of Hill House lead me to believe it is more scary. So sorry in advance to Rowan the horror averse!

I'm on the wait list for the audiobook from the library which is a week or so out, but I might try and look for a second hand copy over the weekend so I can start it on the 1st.
 
Yep, Mar/Apr, May/June, and Nov/Dec are still available. Let me know which block you're interested in.
Question- whats the lineup for next years book club? If we can ask
 
Question- whats the lineup for next years book club? If we can ask
You can. I just don't want to take too much away from the conversation about the actual book or building excitement for Kadi's hosting.

Jan/Feb- Jess
March/April - Rowan
May/June - Daphne
July/August - Sarah
Sept/Oct - Cyndi
Nov/Dec

My book is in transit from another branch, so I should be able to pick it up early next week! It'll be the first time I started reading this close to the start, I think xD
 
Last edited:
Thanks Cyndi!!

I've been burning through the book I'm reading now (Just A Regular Boy by Catherine Ryan Hyde) so I'll need to start tracking down a copy of Haunting of Hill House fast ahaha
 
Can I get the may/june spot for next year maybe?


EDIT: sorry just saw we shouldn't focus too much on that here. I'm tentatively excited about the book, I've never seen the show because I'm a horror baby (though less so in print)
 
Shockingly wasn't able to find a used copy of Hill House but I was determined get a physical copy so I ended up getting a new one x_x

I've only read a chapter so far but I'm really enjoying it. I'm not used to reading older books so the prose is a little harder to get through, for me at least, but it's making me savor it a bit more. And it helps that I find Shirley Jackson's writing pretty fun.

Some moments/quotes I've enjoyed below
I really enjoyed the way the argument Theodora has with her friend is described, "Things were said on both sides which only time could eradicate" and "before they could laugh over them together time would have to go by". Just love how that concept was described.

Eleanor's conversation with her sister and brother-in-law also cracked me up
"I'm taking the car."
"-but what if something happens and we need it-"
"I'm taking the car."
"-its a shame we can't let you take it-
[steals car]
Love that for her. No notes.

Also describing someone leaning on a fence as "elaborately silent" really stuck out to me. Love that.

Hopefully I can keep up reading a chapter at a time here and there to pace myself haha.
 
Eleanor's conversation with her sister and brother-in-law also cracked me up
"I'm taking the car."
"-but what if something happens and we need it-"
"I'm taking the car."
"-its a shame we can't let you take it-
[steals car]
Love that for her. No notes.
YESSS I LOVED THIS LMAO

I'm about 30% through according to my kindle, though the edition I'm reading had a MASSIVE intro so take that with a pinch of salt. This book has officially won my Most Charming Line Of 2024 award though;
-
"Imagine two splendid old picnic-going girls like us," Theodora said, "afraid of a rabbit."
 
I picked up my copy this afternoon and am going to start reading now! I really am digging the eeriness of this cover. If anyone else has a different cover, I'd love to see it!


20240903_145342.jpg
 
I read this last year - and really enjoyed it - so while I won't read it again, i'll follow the discussion along, because I really enjoyed reading it.
 
Finished the book this morning because a certain fluffy young woman decided very adamantly that i was not allowed to sleep and overall I really enjoyed it!

It was definitely a lot less scary than I expected, given its reputation. I would describe it as creepy more than outright scary for the most part, though it did have its moments. The beginning is nice and slow, which makes for great juxtaposition between the unsettling nature of the house and the cheerful lives they're living inside, but once it gets going it really gets going.

My only real complaint was the two characters who showed up at the very end - Mrs. Montague and Arthur. They didn't really add anything to the story for me, instead they just interrupted the tension that had been building so nicely otherwise. I wish that time and attention had been devoted to Eleanor's breakdown instead, so it could properly breathe.

I was surprised by the queer undertones as well - I hadn't expected that, and it was a pleasant surprise for a book of its era. Obviously nothing is overt, but there's so much talk of same-gender life companions, as well as... whatever Theodora and Eleanor have going on, which is fascinating.

What really really stood out to me in this book thought was the prose, oh my god. Everything in this book is so beautifully phrased, I just want to roll around in it. Shirley Jackson has such a lyrical way with words, especially with the weaving in of O Mistress Mine throughout the piece, (one of my favourite sonnets,) and it gives everything such a rich feeling.

All in all, adored this book and wasn't nearly as spooked by it as I expected to be. (Which, for me; yay!) Really really beautiful one, wish it had been longer!
 
I'm only about 40 pages in, but I agree with you both. The prose is really pleasant so far.
 
I am slowly working my way through the book.

I watched the series before reading the book, but I am feeling like it's going in a different direction so far. Maybe it's not, or maybe I don't remember the series very well. I also watched the other one with Victoria Pedretti around the same time so maybe I'm getting them confused.

But she has just tried to pull into the house so hopefully I can get further this week!
 
I watched the series before reading the book, but I am feeling like it's going in a different direction so far. Maybe it's not, or maybe I don't remember the series very well. I also watched the other one with Victoria Pedretti around the same time so maybe I'm getting them confused.
No yeah, I looked up the synopsis for the series after finishing the book, because I thought maybe I'd be able to handle the show if the book hadn't actually spooked me, but it looks like the show has p much a completely different plot. (They made Theodora and Eleanor sisters?!) The latter half of the book especially is so internal that it would definitely be difficult to adapt as written, but the show seems to barely have anything in common with the book at all, I was quite disappointed.
 
No yeah, I looked up the synopsis for the series after finishing the book, because I thought maybe I'd be able to handle the show if the book hadn't actually spooked me, but it looks like the show has p much a completely different plot. (They made Theodora and Eleanor sisters?!) The latter half of the book especially is so internal that it would definitely be difficult to adapt as written, but the show seems to barely have anything in common with the book at all, I was quite disappointed.

Okay, I'm glad that I'm not just confused because I was about to go back and reread everything I had so far, afraid I had missed something xD It's kind of nice as someone who has watched the show because I can now look at it with fresh eyes (with some crossover).
 
I finished my copy!

So the plot was actually a lot more reminiscent of the movie 'The Haunting' from 1999 with Owen Wilson, Liam Neeson, and Catherine Zeta Jones than it was the show itself- the show stole the names and location but not much else. The book was well written- I liked how Nell just went crazy, even if I did get a bit lost sometimes. Could just be because of the chaos I'm in right now but I got whiplash following nells moods- sometimes she hated Theo and sometimes she loved her. It was def more suspenseful than actually horrifying, but those can be just as good. Not my favorite of the year and arthur/mrs montague i'll agree seemed pointless, but it was an interesting read in the end all the same. I also agree that her just stealing the car was really great.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top