Y19 Quidditch
- Thread starter Professor Cyndi Kingsley
- Start date
- Messages
- 53,720
- OOC First Name
- Nick
- Blood Status
- Pure Blood
- Relationship Status
- Married
- Wand
- Curly Oak/Wenge 16" Essence of Feng-huang Tail Feather
- Age
- 1/1989
I can't remember how much was shared or discussed when the new system was announced, but one of the things we identified was we wanted the games to be about roleplaying again. So we wanted to eliminate rules and force people to roleplay unique scenarios and have fun doing it. We could have taken more time to code a more complicated system that kept track of the quaffle and bludgers, that required players to identify their targets for bludger hits, to pass the quaffle using the system and identify who they were trying to pass to - but we feared this would also slow the games down and burden the roleplay. We wanted the system to serve the roleplays: not the roleplays to serve the system.
So, the system is simple. It lets you click a button and it tells you if you succeed, and you have to roleplay that. You could click the button even when it doesn't make sense: a chaser could click to score even if they don't have the quaffle - and that's why we have a referee and it encourages people to follow the actual roleplay as it unfolds.
It also eliminates the tediousness of points from the previous system, and people scheming to ensure their points got the maximum amount of bang-for-their-buck (or so to speak) - it weights players so better players have better odds of succeeding but also adds an element of luck and chance to the game: just like a real sport. Roleplayers aren't very good at being honest about a character's abilities, generally, we all like to roleplay successful people who can do things: not failures who are just bad at stuff or randomly fail sometimes. So this just helps keep things grounded without controlling everything.
[/rant]
So, the system is simple. It lets you click a button and it tells you if you succeed, and you have to roleplay that. You could click the button even when it doesn't make sense: a chaser could click to score even if they don't have the quaffle - and that's why we have a referee and it encourages people to follow the actual roleplay as it unfolds.
It also eliminates the tediousness of points from the previous system, and people scheming to ensure their points got the maximum amount of bang-for-their-buck (or so to speak) - it weights players so better players have better odds of succeeding but also adds an element of luck and chance to the game: just like a real sport. Roleplayers aren't very good at being honest about a character's abilities, generally, we all like to roleplay successful people who can do things: not failures who are just bad at stuff or randomly fail sometimes. So this just helps keep things grounded without controlling everything.
[/rant]
Sergios Romanes
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 322
- Wand
- Curly 15 1/2" Rigid Blackthorn Wand with Thestral Tail Hair Core
- Age
- 8/2018
I'm tempted to have my chaser get so nervous if so many people are around her to drop the quaffle. 
That's really realistic. 
That's really realistic.
- Messages
- 53,720
- OOC First Name
- Nick
- Blood Status
- Pure Blood
- Relationship Status
- Married
- Wand
- Curly Oak/Wenge 16" Essence of Feng-huang Tail Feather
- Age
- 1/1989
You're a Gryffindor. That's maybe a bit too realistic. 
We need to win!
We need to win!
Belladonna Metzger
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 764
- Wand
- Coconut Wand 14 1/4" Essence of Star Dust
- Age
- 11/2022
What happens if Gryffindor loses?
Bridget Riley
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 607
- OOC First Name
- Claire
I love the system. Never played Quidditch before anyway, but it's a lot of fun! Though I'm pretty confused, since my two options are 'Catch snitch' or 'Other action' and I don't know whether I'm allowed to click catch snitch or not 
Or what it'll do!Yeah, Bridget has a bit of a fear of heights so I can see her failing somewhere
Tell ya what, next time I post I'll click it and see what happens
- Messages
- 18,304
- OOC First Name
- Kaitlyn
- Blood Status
- Unknown
- Relationship Status
- Married
- Sexual Orientation
- Pansexual
- Wand
- Cypress/Ebony Mix 14" Core of Basilisk Fang; Black Walnut/Maple 12 3/4" Essense of Silver Thistle
- Age
- October 31, 2007 - November 7, 2039
Well, it would be a Puff doing the dropping.
But I wouldn't want people to think I am playing for just one side.
But I wouldn't want people to think I am playing for just one side.
- Messages
- 36,003
- OOC First Name
- Cyndi
- Blood Status
- Mixed Blood
- Wand
- Knotted 15 Inch Flexible Oak Wand with Meteorite Dust Core
- Age
- 4/2005
Bridget Riley said:
Yeah, Bridget has a bit of a fear of heights so I can see her failing somewhere
Tell ya what, next time I post I'll click it and see what happens
Do it! What could happen is you could catch the snitch.
Kingsley will disown the team. So win.Belladonna Metzger said:<FONT font="georgia">What happens if Gryffindor loses?
Kelsey Ariyah Boneheart
mother to elio; trusting
- Messages
- 919
- Blood Status
- Mixed Blood
- Relationship Status
- Single
- Sexual Orientation
- Heterosexual
- Wand
- Coconut Wand 14 1/4" Essence of Star Dust
- Age
- 7/2020
Poor Kelsey is beside herself. She gets too excited sometimes
Belladonna Metzger
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 764
- Wand
- Coconut Wand 14 1/4" Essence of Star Dust
- Age
- 11/2022
Professor Cyndi Kingsley said:Kingsley will disown the team. So win.Belladonna Metzger said:What happens if Gryffindor loses?
No pressure though, guys.
- Messages
- 53,720
- OOC First Name
- Nick
- Blood Status
- Pure Blood
- Relationship Status
- Married
- Wand
- Curly Oak/Wenge 16" Essence of Feng-huang Tail Feather
- Age
- 1/1989
This is the only appropriate response.Professor Cyndi Kingsley said:Kingsley will disown the team. So win.Belladonna Metzger said:What happens if Gryffindor loses?
Unless a seeker is doing something else important, you should pretty much always be trying to catch that snitch.Bridget Riley said:
You'll fail most of the time. Which is appropriate: the snitch is hard to get. But you could get it in the first few minutes of a game.
Sarah Keith
Mum of two | Reconnected ♥
- Messages
- 519
- OOC First Name
- Mel
- Blood Status
- Half Blood
- Relationship Status
- It's Complicated
- Sexual Orientation
- Heterosexual
- Wand
- Curly 14 Inch Sturdy Yew Wand with Thestral Tail Hair Core
- Age
- 5/2020
Try catching the snitch then! 
We might win!
We might win!
- Messages
- 53,720
- OOC First Name
- Nick
- Blood Status
- Pure Blood
- Relationship Status
- Married
- Wand
- Curly Oak/Wenge 16" Essence of Feng-huang Tail Feather
- Age
- 1/1989
Oh, sorry.Sarah Keith said:Try catching the snitch then!
Did I say try to catch the snitch?
No, no, no.
The goal of the game is to absolutely never catch the snitch.
Ai Nightray
mum • all of it was worth getting here • loyal
- Messages
- 8,627
- OOC First Name
- Marga
- Blood Status
- Mixed Blood
- Relationship Status
- Married
- Sexual Orientation
- Demisexual
- Wand
- Straight 14 1/2 Inch Unyielding Redwood Wand with Augurey Tail Feather Core
- Age
- 11/2018 (33)
Don't be so evil, Nick...Nicolas King said:Oh, sorry.Sarah Keith said:Try catching the snitch then!
Did I say try to catch the snitch?
No, no, no.
The goal of the game is to absolutely never catch the snitch.
Bridget Riley
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 607
- OOC First Name
- Claire
Ooooh.. I wasted like 3 posts then! Don't blame me if we lose, blame Bridget. Silly Bridget
Also, if I try and fail to catch the snitch, am I allowed to RP that actually happening? (Probably, I just hate getting things wrong )
Also, if I try and fail to catch the snitch, am I allowed to RP that actually happening? (Probably, I just hate getting things wrong
)
- Messages
- 53,720
- OOC First Name
- Nick
- Blood Status
- Pure Blood
- Relationship Status
- Married
- Wand
- Curly Oak/Wenge 16" Essence of Feng-huang Tail Feather
- Age
- 1/1989
You definitely should. Any time you press a button, that's an RP post - success or failure, you do what it says.Bridget Riley said:Also, if I try and fail to catch the snitch, am I allowed to RP that actually happening? (Probably, I just hate getting things wrong
But roleplaying a failure shouldn't always be "it was just centimetres away, did a sudden dive, and was completely gone." - sometimes it might just be you thought you saw it but it was the sun's glare off some guy's glasses in the stands.
Bridget Riley
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 607
- OOC First Name
- Claire
Ahh, perfect explanation. Thank youNicolas King said:You definitely should. Any time you press a button, that's an RP post - success or failure, you do what it says.Bridget Riley said:Also, if I try and fail to catch the snitch, am I allowed to RP that actually happening? (Probably, I just hate getting things wrong
But roleplaying a failure shouldn't always be "it was just centimetres away, did a sudden dive, and was completely gone." - sometimes it might just be you thought you saw it but it was the sun's glare off some guy's glasses in the stands.
- Messages
- 36,003
- OOC First Name
- Cyndi
- Blood Status
- Mixed Blood
- Wand
- Knotted 15 Inch Flexible Oak Wand with Meteorite Dust Core
- Age
- 4/2005
Who will be the first to score? 
Ai Nightray
mum • all of it was worth getting here • loyal
- Messages
- 8,627
- OOC First Name
- Marga
- Blood Status
- Mixed Blood
- Relationship Status
- Married
- Sexual Orientation
- Demisexual
- Wand
- Straight 14 1/2 Inch Unyielding Redwood Wand with Augurey Tail Feather Core
- Age
- 11/2018 (33)
I have no idea..
Sarah Keith
Mum of two | Reconnected ♥
- Messages
- 519
- OOC First Name
- Mel
- Blood Status
- Half Blood
- Relationship Status
- It's Complicated
- Sexual Orientation
- Heterosexual
- Wand
- Curly 14 Inch Sturdy Yew Wand with Thestral Tail Hair Core
- Age
- 5/2020
Sarah failed! I want her to be first
I want her to be first Belladonna Metzger
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 764
- Wand
- Coconut Wand 14 1/4" Essence of Star Dust
- Age
- 11/2022
Professor Cyndi Kingsley said:Who will be the first to score?
If it's not Gryffindor will we be punished? 
Peter Lurken
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 294
- OOC First Name
- Pat
- Sexual Orientation
- Hetrosexual
- Wand
- Maple Wand 7 3/4" With Essence of Salamander Bone
- Age
- 6/2019
Lets not find out shall we? Gryffindor quaffle is up for grabsBelladonna Metzger said:Professor Cyndi Kingsley said:Who will be the first to score?If it's not Gryffindor will we be punished?
Belladonna Metzger
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 764
- Wand
- Coconut Wand 14 1/4" Essence of Star Dust
- Age
- 11/2022
I have to wait for the timer.
Sarah Keith
Mum of two | Reconnected ♥
- Messages
- 519
- OOC First Name
- Mel
- Blood Status
- Half Blood
- Relationship Status
- It's Complicated
- Sexual Orientation
- Heterosexual
- Wand
- Curly 14 Inch Sturdy Yew Wand with Thestral Tail Hair Core
- Age
- 5/2020
I like this idea! Can we find out please?Belladonna Metzger said:Professor Cyndi Kingsley said:Who will be the first to score?If it's not Gryffindor will we be punished?
- Messages
- 2,729
- OOC First Name
- Teigs
- Sexual Orientation
- Very Conservative
- Wand
- Holly/Ebony Wand 12 1/2 Essence of Griffin Feather
- Age
- 6/2004
(Posting as a Gryffindor here)
How about we use both the Beaters to hit a bludger at Sarah
How about we use both the Beaters to hit a bludger at Sarah