Freya was probably right, Evan thought, as the two had chatted their concoction had simmered away for long enough and it was finally time for the taste test. Evan reached for two goblets from a shelf nearby, feeling there was no need to summon something so close to her with magic after having such a successful first try- she didn't want to push her luck. Evan remembered Freya's fun little make believe scenario, and quickly jumped back into character.
"It's ready, alright! Now, if it's perfect, you and I should be able enjoy it as a delightful hot cup of cocoa, but if this specific brew were ever served to an evil big old meanie then all of their evil big old meanie thoughts and desires would be forever gone, destroyed by the power of chocolate and cinnamon and the joy of having a warm and full belly!" As Evan went on her voice became increasingly more excited and higher pitched, and by the time she was done speaking she was standing on her tiptoes, waving her arms (and the goblets) triumphantly above her head. In her excitement she lost her balance, wobbling drastically to regain her composure. She came dangerously close to knocking over the cauldron, but, perhaps protected by the power from the magical chocolate concoction nearby, Evan managed to find her footing.
She burst into laughter, barely holding it together enough to finally scoop two portions of cocoa from the cauldron and into the goblets. She offered the second one to Freya, lifting her own to her mouth and taking the first careful sip. "Oh.. My.. Gosh.." Evan paused, carefully considering the taste and what word she could use to describe it... "It's DREADFUL!" She began to roar with laughter, and managed to carefully place the goblet of terrible cocoa on the closest flat surface she could find before falling onto the floor and curling into a ball, giggling and clutching at her ribcage, imagining that the only way that this cocoa would defeat any dark witch or wizard would be by poisoning them.