Dear J,
I'm glad to hear from you again, but I'm sorry it's under such bad circumstances. Your family situation definitely sounds difficult. Parents separating is never easy, it can feel a lot like the world doesn't make sense anymore when things you thought were permanent change in such a major way. If your parents are pretending everything's fine it sounds like maybe they're having difficulty understanding how this is affecting you. I might be wrong, but it sounds like they want to do their best to keep things the way they always were, to keep things stable for you, but that's not always helpful when you need to talk about how things are changing. It can wind up feeling more unstable, when you don't know what's really going on.
Do you think you can talk to your parents about these feelings? If you would feel unsafe doing so, you should be the judge of that, but I think it would help them a lot to hear from you what you need. As your parents they should want to do the best for you through this, and if what they're trying isn't working they need to know, so they can figure out how to handle this. You sound clever and emotionally mature enough to have these difficult conversations, but it can be difficult for parents to see that sometimes. Try to talk to them seriously, and show them that you can handle the subject maturely.
Parents always want to seem like superheroes in their kids eyes, like they know the answer to every question, and never do anything wrong, but the truth is of course that parents are just people. Everybody makes mistakes sometimes, and everybody hurts somebody else sometimes. And it can be easier to hurt someone else's feelings by mistake when your own feelings are hurt. Your parents are probably hurting a lot from the separation, and finding it hard not knowing what to do. If you're not sure how to approach the subject with them, it might be a good idea to acknowledge that this is hurting them too, and looking at it as a conversation between people who are all going through a tough time right now. It might make it easier for them to see what you need to feel better if you take a first step on the subject.
One thing I want to make clear is that you shouldn't be blaming yourself for what happened. However much trouble you got into, I promise it's not the reason your parents separated. Marriages don't end over a few fights, and there are always things parents keep private from their kids. If the fights over your behaviour were the only thing you saw before the separation it would be easy to feel that way, but I'm sure this wasn't your fault. Grownups are responsible for their own decisions, and there are a lot of things that go into making a marriage work or fail.
I do have kids, I have four children. My three daughters are at Hogwarts, and I have a son at home who will be at school in a few years. I don't know what year you're in, but one of my girls might be one of your classmates.
It can be hard sometimes to know whether you like someone romantically, or just as a friend. Think about how you think you would feel doing more romantic things with him. Holding hands, or going on a date, things like that. If those thoughts make you happy, you might have romantic feelings for him, but it can be hard to tell sometimes. Do you know how he feels about the kiss? It's hard for me to know what to say without more information, but my general advice is always just to think about these things, and think about which thought makes you happiest. If going on a date with him makes you happy, then that's the way to go, but if you think you would be happier just spending time with him as friends, then that's your answer. For romantic feelings, the only thing you can trust is your own gut. And remember, if someone else has romantic feelings for you, but you realise you don't return them, that's nothing to feel guilty about. We don't control our feelings, and you should never feel pressured to feel something you don't.
I wish I could say that life gets less confusing, but even grownups are confused all the time. That's our big secret, everyone is just pretending they know what they're doing. Even if you're still confused though, over time you get more practice at making decisions and understanding how you want to go about things. Your teenage years are sort of the training ground for learning these skills, in how to talk to people and listen to your own inner voice. It's okay to make mistakes, and it's okay not to know what you're doing all the time. Every time life confuses you, it's an opportunity to learn and grow as a person.
I hope this was some help, feel free to write back or come in and see me any time you like.
Looking forward to hearing from you,
Maria Madison